Hello dear
Welcome To Nick's Pizzaria and Wings
Nestled in the heart of Plant City, Nick's Pizzaria and Wings offers a delightful dining experience characterized by its inviting atmosphere and friendly service. Celebrated for its hand-breaded onion rings and irresistible calzones, each dish reflects a commitment to quality and flavor. Customers rave about the old-school New York style pizza, while the made-from-scratch meatballs in their spaghetti dish garner high praise. Despite some mixed experiences, the restaurant's dedication to customer satisfaction shines, as they promptly rectify mistakes and ensure patrons leave happy. Whether dining in or opting for takeout, Nick's has become a beloved favorite for pizza lovers in the area.
About
Nick's Pizzaria and Wings
Welcome to Nick's Pizzaria and Wings, a hidden gem located at 1707 James L Redman Pkwy D, Plant City, FL. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this delightful establishment promises an unforgettable culinary experience that will keep you coming back for more.
Step inside, and you're greeted by a warm, inviting atmosphere filled with historic charm and friendly faces. The attentive staff, passionate about their craft, are eager to ensure you have everything you need for a memorable meal. As you peruse the menu, you'll discover that Nick's is renowned for its New York-style pizza, calzones, and mouthwatering wings. Don't miss the hand-breaded onion rings served with a delectable sriracha aioli—perfect for those who enjoy a bit of heat with their crunch.
One enthusiastic diner, Nat At8, raved about the calzones, describing the breading as “incredible” and praising the generous portions that could easily serve multiple guests. It's a testament to the hearty portions that Nick's offers, making it an ideal spot for family gatherings or a casual night out with friends. However, they also recommend ensuring your calzone is served hot to savor its fullest flavor.
For those with a penchant for burgers, Nick’s BBQ Bacon Burger and the Breath Burger are standout choices, complemented by handmade meatballs that have charmed many guests, including Jasmine's family who regard Nick's as a regular take-out favorite. Each dish is a celebration of taste, made with care and attention to detail.
Interestingly, Nick's has seen its share of ups and downs, with some customers voicing concerns over portion sizes and topping accuracy. Yet, what truly sets Nick's Pizzaria apart is their willingness to listen and adapt. One satisfied customer shared how the owner personally rectified a previous mistake, transforming a disappointing experience into a glowing review. This commitment to customer satisfaction is a rare find in today's dining landscape.
Whether you’re indulging in a classic pizza or a sumptuous calzone, Nick’s offers something for everyone, all while upholding a high standard of quality. With an emphasis on fresh ingredients and genuine hospitality, it’s clear why Nick's Pizzaria and Wings has earned such loyal patrons.
So the next time you're in Plant City, make sure to stop by Nick's Pizzaria and Wings for your fix of incredible pie and wings. You might just discover your new favorite local spot!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ I recently had the pleasure of dining at Nicks, and it was an outstanding experience! The onion rings were very well done hand breaded and the siracha aioli dipping sauce is a perfect mix if you like a little spice. The Calzone was absolutely fantastic, the breading was incredible, i can’t get over how delicious it was, i got a large, thinking it wouldn’t be very big, as i do eat quite a lot, but the small would have sufficed for one, the large was very good sized potentially serving up to 4 ,depending of course. The staff was incredibly friendly and attentive, making sure I had everything I needed. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, perfect for a casual meal or a night out with friends. I highly recommend Nicks Pizzaria and Wings, to anyone looking for amazing Calzones – I can't wait to go back! My only downside and I feel the need to at least mention it, was the fact that my calzone was slightly undercooked, but it’s an understandable mistake based on how large the serving is. Just make sure yours is hot! I’m very positive the staff would be happy to fix it if it wasn’t done perfectly, I ate mine however with no issues. ”
“ Let me just say this has been our go to pizza place since we moved to plant city. They have 40% gone down hill. Multiple times weve ordered and have had problems with the accuracy. I took a picture of tonight's pie: pepperoni. I can't see justifying a price increase for such small and dull pepperoni. There is literally two pieces of pepperoni on the slice. It's sadder than homeless puppies. It's like they just said "screw it" and picked the pepperoni up from Publix. (Before the owner chimes in: please look at pictures and reviews before this. The pepperoni is the size of a nickel in the photo I posted.) Before there used to be a good amount of cheese on the pizza. Now you pretty much have to order extra cheese to even get an appropriate amount. If the sauce is literally breaking through the cheese, you have stingy cooks, or a resturaunt cutting back on costs to make more money. Really sad with the way this place has been going over the last two years. If we weren't hungry, we would have asked for a refund. Edit: After speaking with the owner, they made us a new pizza, and honestly it came out great, and every time we've ordered, it's come out great again. I've changed the review to five stars. Not many places would be willing to not only admit they were wrong, but also correct the mistakes that were made. Glad to have some good pizza in plant city again! ”
“ Since moving to Plant City, Nick's Pizzaria has become a regular fav for my family. We usually order delivery or take-out. The service is always quick and the delivery driver has always been polite. The meatballs in the spaghetti dish are made from scratch, they were so perfectly formed, not to soft not to firm and we'll seasoned. The BBQ Bacon burger & The Breath Burger are personal faves as well. ”
“ This was the best pizza we have had in a while omg so delicious the service was awesome the staff were so polite the garlic knots are the boom just a great place to stop and pick up and go we live in Arcadia Florida so we are 2 hours away and where in the area and found Nick's one word to me phenomenal omg ”
“ First time trying Nick’s pizza and it was fantastic. Very old school New York style pizza. The place is small but cozy and has historic pictures of Plant city hanging on the walls. The gentleman at the cash register couldn’t have been nicer. He made great suggestions on food. 10/10. Definitely try this place out. ”
“ Absolutely fantastic!! Would give ten stars if I could. Best cheese steak I've had on Florida and I'm from the Philly area. Delivery was faster than they told me. Pizza was very good. Slightly over cooked but not to the point where they shouldn't have sent it. Bronx sampler @ 16.99 is great for two if you haven't been here and want to try out their menu. You can see the full menu on their website ”
“ Had a wonderful experience at Nick's with my family. Friendly service, quality ingredients, made with love. This was my first time eating at Nick's and I've lived in the area for over 20 years. This gem is situated near Southern Hospitality and is an enjoyable experience. The kids had a blast making their own breadsticks. You should try it if you haven't, I didn't know what I was missing until I went. ”
“ 1st time visit and it was the best. Customer service is phenomenal. Ordered the lunch special, which was a meatball Sub and Mozzarella sticks. Delicious, and the staff was remarkable. Great atmosphere and on the list for another visit ”